ALERT: BC Premier says she doesn’t know about Public Guardian misconduct


Yesterday BC Premier Christy Clark responded to a caller’s question about the Public Guardian & Trustee on CBC Radio’s province-wide BC Almanac show:


CALLER JOANNE from Cowichan asked, “When is the government going to conduct a forensic, financial and policy review of the Public Guardian and Trustee?”


PREMIER CLARK responded:  “Hmmm. That’s not a question I’ve given a lot of thought to in the past… I haven’t been in receipt of a lot of complaints about the way the Public Trustee has worked.”

[to listen to the complete call-in show podcast, see link below]

Premier Clark’s response is misleading in the extreme.

She and the government have received scores of complaints from the public about blatant misconduct by the Office of the Public Guardian & Trustee.

Even the B.C. Ombudsperson, in a recent report to the entire legislature, rebuked the Public Guardian, saying that the Office of the Ombudsperson “began to investigate (the PGT) after complaints about how the province’s Public Guardian and Trustee had taken over the legal and financial affairs of thousands of people,” resulting in a report, “No Longer Your Decision,” provided to the Premier’s office in February 2013.

Seniors at Risk routinely receives complaints from people across British Columbia about the PGT. The documents provided to us reveal systemic wrong-doing, and shockingly abusive and negligent treatment of BC citizens by the Public Guardian & Trustee. These abuses of legal and human rights have been happening for years, and the B.C. government has been made aware of them, but apparently not Premier Christy Clark. Perhaps it is time the Premier was briefed.

Premier Clark concluded her response to the caller by saying:

“If you have some real concerns about that, can I ask you to send it to me so I can have a look at it and I’ll get back to you directly about it.”

Accept Premier Clark’s invitation!

Give the Premier an opportunity to learn more about the misconduct of the Public Guardian and Trustee. Let her know if you have had, or are having, a bad experience with the PGT, or if you know of others who have. Everyone should be concerned. These are our taxpayer dollars being spent, not to help, but to intimidate and harm B.C. citizens.



Premier Christy Clark
Victoria, BC 
V8W 9E1

Or EMAIL your concerns to the manager of the Correspondence Branch of the Premier’s office at:

And please SEND A COPY of your letter or email to Seniors at Risk:

Seniors at Risk will help ensure that the government doesn’t ignore your complaint – or the magnitude of the systemic abuse of citizens’ rights, freedoms and assets by the Public Guardian and Trustee.


2013-05-02 CBC call-in show Christy Clark-PGT podcast clip

Listen to the entire call-in show podcast here:

Scroll down the page on the right hand side to find the link to the show’s podcasts.

Then, scroll down the Featured Audio list to find Christy Clark takes questions on BC Almanac.

Caller Joanne’s question is near the end of the show, at about the 17:20 mark.



Here are just a few of stories that support the radio show caller’s plea to Premier Clark for “the government to conduct a forensic, financial and policy review of the Public Guardian and Trustee”:

Phyllis Lowdell, Vancouver BC:  Public “Trustee’ caught stealing $1.26 million in assets from two seniors

Sheila Scholnick, Vancouver, BC:  BC public guardian accused of abusing rights

Jean Wilder, Invermere BC:  Jean Wilder still being held unlawfully, PGT applies to seize control of her assets

George Brent, Trail BC:  B.C. man loses right to care for wife

Charlie & Stella, Vancouver Island, BC:  Public Guardian’s bait ‘n switch routine

Ombudsperson Report on the Office of the Public Guardian & Trustee, February 2013, full report: “No Longer Your Decision”

Focus magazine, March 2013:  Ombudsperson pans incapability assessments


Just the tip of the iceberg – a comprehensive inquiry is essential

As many people who have had to engage with the Public Guardian & Trustee’s office will know, the Ombudsperson’s report barely touches on the epidemic of systemic misconduct by the PGT. Many aspects of highly questionable PGT conduct were either not mentioned or glossed over in the Ombudsperson’s 186-page report.

It is one thing to write reports suggesting changes and to make public statements professing to comply with the law and the recommendations; it’s quite another to actually ‘walk the talk’. Seniors at Risk is currently working on cases involving the PGT, and it is clear that the attitude and tactics of this very powerful, very secretive unaccountable organization remains much as it was prior to the Ombudsperson’s report.

As the caller Joanne put it to Premier Clark, when will the government conduct a forensic, financial and policy review of the PGT? A comprehensive inquiry into the Office of the B.C. Public Guardian & Trustee is clearly long overdue.


Knowledge. Compassion. Courage. Action.

Take a stand against elder abuse by the Public Guardian & Trustee.  

Be Sociable, Share!


  1. PREMIER RE: PGT MISCONDUCT… It’s not just that the PGT are charging big bucks to spend a vulnerable person’s money, it’s that they are doing so as poor stewards of the apprehended person’s wealth. The PGT is like someone appointed by the court to pay a person’s bills who then goes crazy deciding to buy a Rolls Royce and chocolate fudge sundaes for breakfast for people who can afford only a Volkswagen and are diabetic. There’s no common sense, and no way to even reason with these people if your family member has had their estate taken over by the health care police.

    Can you imagine the community sending an errand boy to buy some groceries, but he comes back with a pound of peanut butter. You challenge him on the purchase and he replies ‘I have the responsibility, its my decision’. You tell him the fridge of the old lady is full, that you are making certain she eats well. And the brat continues to spend her money sending her weekly bags of candies and pop. He doesn’t consult the person who is going to eat. He doesn’t consult the family and neighbours about the person’s tastes in food or health conditions, because it’s ‘up to him’ he says. He’s the decider.

    What arrogance!

    Comment by Bettsy K. — May 4, 2013 @ 8:34 am

  2. PREMIER RE: PGT MISCONDUCT… Thank you so much for that.

    Comment by Ruth — May 4, 2013 @ 10:05 am

  3. PREMIER RE: PGT MISCONDUCT… When I reported abuse, they ignored my letters and phone calls, or informed me everything was confidential. I have sent copies to the premier’s office regarding my disgust with the Public Trustee and Guardian, Ombudperson, Fraser Health, R.C.M.P and others. Why should the public pay for these services if they are just…pie in the sky??? There is NO HELP available for seniors – any bully can take advantage. I hope the top blows off ELDER ABUSE and many will speak out without fear of being ignored – again and again.

    Comment by Steaming Senior — May 4, 2013 @ 2:38 pm

  4. PREMIER RE: PGT MISCONDUCT… We were approached by the PGT like they were some charity or advocacy group, oh so concerned over my mother’s finances, how they would assist, put things in order, etc. Would they be taking over anything but technical management, we asked? No, family would decide they said, they would just pay the bills. This was a lie. The PGT took over control of my mother’s finances without family input, as in a trial. I was not invited to give my say. No one in my family was. Neither were neighbours and friends invited to give their understanding of family dynamics and my mothers relationships and finances. We were originally keen to see the PGT take over my mother’s finances as there were accusations within the family (including by myself) of financial impropriety by one of my siblings and other complicating factors. However, not only did the PGT not properly attend to the sensible solution, they have proved to be uncaring, lazy and expensive. It’s my mother who is now suffering because of the costly, foolish and even cruel decisions being made by these unaccountable bureaucrats. I advise eveyone to stay clear away from the Public Guardian. They are pretending to be something they are not in order to lure people in. Once the PGT have you in their clutches, you can’t get out.

    Comment by Jon&Maddy — May 6, 2013 @ 7:00 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Comment moderation is in effect. Please do not submit your comment twice -- your comment will display once it has been approved by a moderator.

back to top LW